Get To Know Us



Loving people into a relationship with Jesus Christ.

Staff & Leadership

Ashton Stewart,
Senior Minister 
Ashton grew up with the most wonderfully dramatic family on earth which has served to teach him a lifetime of lessons on grace. In college he met his best friend in the world and on July 31, he married her. Ashton and Amber have been married fifteen blissful years. At the end of year five, they welcomed their first addition to the family, Ella Joy. At the end of year seven, they welcomed their second bundle of joy, Liana Grace to the mix. And in April 2015 their newest addition, Judson Thomas, joined the Stewart clan. Ashton graduated from Central Christian College of the Bible in 2006 with a Bachelor’s Degree in General Ministry. In addition to his Bible College education, he’s attended Indiana Wesleyan University to study business administration and Lincoln Christian University to study Greek and Theology. In his free time, Ashton enjoys reading with a cup of coffee (preferably Starbuck Veranda blend), grilling marinated meat, watching sports (especially college basketball, i.e. the University of Kentucky) and loving on his family.
Kurt Smith,
Associate Minister 
The newest addition to the team, Kurt and Amber are moving from Callao, MO with their four kids: Kayanna, Riley, Aryn, and Brevan. (Famously known as the Smith Pack). Kurt graduated from Central Christian College of the Bible in 2005 with a B.A. in Youth & Family Ministry and a year later married Amber. Kurt’s ministry here will focus on worship, communications, and helping share the load in any way he can.

Dustin Britton,
Youth Minister 


Dustin grew  up in Veedersburg, IN. He  graduated from Fountain Central High School in 2002 and was a member of Sterling Christian Church. He then went to Vincennes University and eventually transferred to Lincoln Christian University. He graduated from LCU’s Hargrove School in 2011 where he received a Bachelor of Arts in General/Youth Ministry.

He met his wife Kim while attending LCU.Kim graduated from LCU and Illinois State University with degrees in Bible and History. She is currently a high school history teacher. She is originally from Fairview Heights, IL.

Matt & Kara Porter,
Children’s Ministry 


We would like to welcome back Matt and Kara Porter as our Children’s Ministry Directors. Matt and Kara were members of Cayuga Christian Church in the past and served in various areas of the youth program. Matt is a local boy who grew up in Dana and graduated from North Vermillion. He currently works for ISU as the manager of their Outdoor Recreation Center. Kara is from Terre Haute and currently teaches at North Vermillion Elementary. Needless to say, they are passionate about our community and kids and are excited about joining the ministry team at Cayuga Christian.
NOW HIRING… Administrative Assistant
Check out the Job Description.
Want to apply?  Download the Job Application.
Pre-School Staff: 
Heather Medina, Kim Bailey, and Elaine Ingram 
Janitorial Staff: 

Randee Bennett and Joey Tolbert


Elders are men who are nominated by the church members and serve as the overseers of the ministry of the church body for a two-year term. The qualifications (traits) of an Elder are scripturally specified in 1 Timothy 3:1-13 and Titus 1:5-9.

What We Believe 

Please download our full doctrinal statement.